Finding Your First Church Home: Real Estate Options for New Church Plants

One of the most practical early decisions every church planter must make is where to gather. Your meeting space affects more than your Sunday setup—it impacts your visibility, financial health, ministry flexibility, and long-term momentum.

Here’s a breakdown of the three primary options—short-term leases, full-time leases, and purchasing property—along with key legal considerations to keep in mind.

1. Leasing for Specific Times (Schools, Community Centers, Theaters)

Many new churches start by renting space from a school, community center, or theater. These facilities are typically available for a few hours on Sundays and sometimes midweek.

Pros

  • Lower startup and overhead costs

  • Flexible agreements without long-term commitments

  • Often located in central or high-traffic areas

Cons

  • Requires weekly setup and teardown

  • Limited access for midweek events or offices

  • No long-term asset or property equity

This is a great launchpad for early-stage churches who need affordability and visibility without long-term obligations.

2. Leasing a 24/7 Facility

A 24/7 lease provides your church with dedicated access to a space—offices, kids’ rooms, sanctuary space—whenever you need it.

Pros

  • Allows for weekday ministries, small groups, and admin functions

  • Creates a consistent location and stronger brand identity

  • Can be customized or built out to suit your needs

Cons

  • Higher lease payments, utilities, and maintenance

  • Long-term contracts may limit flexibility

  • Some landlords impose restrictions on use or alterations

This option is ideal for churches ready to grow into a full weekly rhythm with ongoing discipleship, outreach, and midweek gatherings.

 3. Purchasing a Building

Buying property offers the greatest control and long-term value but also comes with the greatest financial commitment.

Pros

  • Full ownership and control of the space

  • Builds equity and long-term financial strength

  • Establishes a sense of permanence and credibility in the community

Cons

  • High upfront costs for purchase and renovations

  • Ongoing maintenance and repair responsibilities

  • May limit future flexibility if growth outpaces space 

While rarely the first move, purchasing can be a powerful next step as your church matures and expands.

What to Look for in a Lease Agreement

No matter which path you take, understanding your lease is essential. Churches have unique needs, so every lease should be reviewed with those in mind. Focus on these areas:

  • Rental amount, frequency, and any annual increases

  • Length of term and renewal options

  • Termination clauses and exit strategies

  • Zoning compliance and restrictions on religious use

  • Responsibility for maintenance and repairs

  • Whether the lease is Triple Net (NNN)—meaning you pay property taxes, insurance, and maintenance in addition to rent

Even if you're just leasing for Sunday mornings, don’t sign anything without reviewing the fine print.

Final Thoughts: Real Estate Is a Spiritual Decision, Too

Choosing a space isn’t just strategic—it’s spiritual. Where you meet shapes how you minister, grow, and serve your community. It sets the tone for everything from outreach to discipleship.

The good news? You don’t have to navigate it alone.

Glenn S. Reynolds, DMin, Jd

Glenn is a speaker, ordained pastor, writer, and attorney living in Suffolk, VA. Before starting Reynolds Law Group, Glenn pastored one of the largest churches in America and was the Director of Church Planting for the Iowa Ministry Network. Glenn roots hard for the Kentucky Wildcats in basketball, the Baltimore Orioles in baseball, and the Iowa Hawkeyes in football.

To learn more about Glenn, you can read his full bio here.

You can find him on Instagram @glennsreynolds

Previous
Previous

Church Planter’s Launch Checklist

Next
Next

Staffing Your New Church Plant: Employment Essentials for Ministry Startups